A New Baseline for Valuing Private Assets in Retail Funds

|
| Print
Authors:

Key Takeaways


  • A new ICI and PwC survey offers a first-of-its-kind look at how investment managers value private assets in retail alternative investment products. Drawing on responses from 39 participants representing different business models, fund structures, and private-market strategies, the research highlights the importance of established governance, outside expertise, and ongoing monitoring.
     
  • Third-party specialists play a major role in private-asset valuation. More than 80% of respondents in private credit, private equity, and REITs use outside valuation experts, while management overrides of third-party valuations are uncommon.
     
  • Investment managers rely on established oversight practices to keep valuations current. Firms use cross-functional committees, board reporting, back-testing, and interim monitoring to assess valuations and respond to new information. The survey found that 63% of respondents reported that significant events materially affecting NAV trigger an immediate review of valuation models. 

 

Established governance structures, outside valuation expertise, and ongoing monitoring are central features of how firms value private assets held in retail alternative products, according to ICI and PwC’s new Retail Alternatives Valuation Benchmarking Survey, which provides a first-of-its-kind look at valuation practices across these products and private asset classes.

The findings show that investment management firms rely on cross-functional committees and regular board reporting for governance, third-party specialists for outside expertise, back-testing to assess prior valuations, and interim monitoring to identify information that may warrant valuation updates.

The survey, which included 39 respondents representing a range of business models, product structures, and private-market strategies, provides a snapshot of how participating firms are approaching valuation questions across different assets and products, without prescribing a single model or best practice.

Third-Party Experts Play a Significant Role

One of the survey’s clearest findings is the widespread use of third-party valuation experts, particularly for direct private assets, including private credit and private equity.

Eighty-six percent of private credit respondents, 85% of private equity respondents, and 82% of REIT respondents reported using third-party valuation experts. Separately, 59% of private credit respondents reported using third-party valuation experts daily, underscoring how closely outside specialists can be integrated into ongoing valuation processes. Use was considerably lower among fund of funds respondents, at 41%, reflecting structures that often rely on valuations provided by underlying investment managers.

Specialized expertise is a major reason firms turn to outside providers. Their role extends beyond valuation calculations to areas such as data validation, market intelligence, price verification, and operational support.

Just as notable is what happens after firms receive those outside inputs. Management overrides are uncommon: between 77% and 100% of respondents across the asset classes surveyed said overrides occur rarely or never. When adjustments are made, they are most commonly driven by more current internal information rather than disagreement with the valuation methodology; respondents also cited model differences and market dislocations.

Valuation Remains a Challenge to Product Expansion

Respondents also identified valuation as an important challenge when expanding into registered fund structures for retail investors.

Among survey participants with a historical focus on alternative funds, 67% identified valuation as a challenge, while 41% cited regulatory considerations. Respondents also pointed to issues related to personnel and talent, tax, board oversight, operational challenges, and asset-servicing.

Valuation and regulation are distinct considerations, but they often intersect as firms include private-market strategies in retail-oriented products. Less-liquid investments can require more complex valuation methodologies, governance processes and controls suited to those investments and product terms, and operating systems capable of supporting the reporting and oversight requirements of products that permit daily investor activity.

Those challenges matter as interest in these products grows. Among survey respondents, 92% had launched or were actively exploring interval funds, a structure that can broaden retail access to private markets while creating new demands on valuation and oversight processes, in part because investors may be able to buy shares daily.

Established Governance Meets New Technology

The survey suggests that firms continue to rely on established governance structures to oversee private-asset valuation. Boards and valuation committees receive information on back-testing, exceptions, overrides, and changes in outside providers. Back-testing compares prior valuations with subsequent market evidence, helping firms assess whether existing approaches remain appropriate. That oversight extends beyond scheduled valuation cycles: 63% of respondents reported that significant events such as covenant breaches materially affecting NAV trigger an immediate review of valuation models.

Firms are also beginning to use technology to support those processes. Respondents reported using AI for tasks such as reviewing deal documents, conducting research, and preparing valuation models. The main obstacles to adoption—data quality, legacy systems, and regulatory uncertainty—suggest that in the near term technology is more likely to strengthen and scale existing valuation workflows than to replace traditional governance or human judgment.

A Starting Point for Continued Work

Taken together, the survey shows firms building private-asset valuation processes around outside expertise, structured oversight, and increasingly sophisticated data and technology tools. It also highlights the practical constraints that remain, particularly around timely information and operational scale. That makes the survey a useful baseline for tracking how valuation practices evolve as retail alternative products expand their use of private-market investments.